|Season 1, Episode 1|
|Original Broadcast Date||February 28, 2015|
|Written by|| Sue Tenney (story by)|
Bruce Graham (teleplay by)
|Directed by||Craig Pryce|
The Good Witch's Wonder
Inside Grey House, a lone figure appears in front of the portrait of the Grey Lady and lights a lantern to illuminate the night. Next door, a man and his son are trying to get a key out of a lockbox with very little luck. Cassie Nightingale appears out of the darkness, lantern in hand, to meet them. The new neighbors say hello, and introduce themselves as Sam Radford and his son Nick. Cassie urges Sam to try the lock again, and when he does it opens! Looks like Cassie still has that “magic” touch.
The next day, while George and Cassie are having breakfast in Grey House, George comments on Lori’s article in a magazine and mentions how proud he is of his grandchildren. Cassie confirms that Lori will be returning home to Middleton for Jake’s memorial ceremony. Upstairs, Cassie’s daughter Grace isn’t having much luck with her wardrobe choices on her first day of high school, but George assures her she’ll be a beauty. She does not agree.
Meanwhile next door, Sam meets with his realtor, Ryan, at the house. Cassie soon stops by with some of her own herbal tea for them both. Cassie notes that Sam is a doctor, judging by his personalized license plate. The two bicker over the benefits and risks of caffeine, and he is surprised to hear that Cassie dabbles in reading medical journals.
At the courthouse, Mayor Martha Tinsdale and new Police Chief Derek Sanders discuss Jake’s dedication service. Derek reassures her that everything has been taken care of and that it will go smoothly.
Brandon and Tara are at the café and discuss her upcoming class load. Tara tells Brandon he really must tell Cassie about his big decision. Their marriage is a little rocky, and for now, two say goodbye to take some time apart.
Cassie’s daughter Grace and her pal Anthony are walking outside of school and talk about the new kid Nick—her new neighbor, and Sam’s son. Anthony predicts that by the end of the year Nick will be captain of the football team and that all the girls will be in love with him. As Grace walks into school, she mutters, “Not this girl.”
Cassie catches up with Sam, this time at his new doctor’s office, just down the block from her store Bell, Book and Candle. Cassie recommends a local handyman to help Sam with the front door, which will not close easily. When a bird unexpected flies into the office, Sam is stunned when Cassie lures the bird closer to perch on her arm. She gently points the bird toward the open door and away he flies. Sam agrees to call the handyman and take Cassie’s advice. Later, Ryan stops by Sam’s office and Ryan lets him know that Cassie has been treating most of Middleton’s patients with her own blend of advice and attention.
Stephanie stops by the Bell, Book and Candle and gushes about their new local Dr. McDreamy. She’s ready to book an appointment with him to cure her own loneliness! Stephanie asks if Cassie is lonely as well since losing Jake. Cassie says it would be hard to recreate what she shared with Jake twice in one lifetime. Brandon stops by for a visit as well but walks out in a hurry before sharing his news.
Mayor Martha meets Dr. Sam for the first time in the local cafe. He complains about the state of the office he has rented—she swore it was state of the art--and Martha assures him that she is sure he will recoup his costs for upgrades being the only doctor in Middleton. When Martha tells him that she has selected him to be the speaker for the upcoming ladies auxiliary meeting, Sam turns her down and states he will be fixing up the office space instead!
Grace pays a visit next door to officially meet the new neighbors. Nick complains that Middleton is too slow for him and that he wants to get back to New York City. Grace is not impressed.
That same day, Cassie senses that something is wrong with George and finds him in the garage bent over in pain. Sam appears as well and checks George out. Cassie talks about the herbs she has been giving George, and Sam is concerned that George has stopped taking a previously prescribed medication without consulting with a doctor. George turns down Sam’s offer of a free visit and checkup. Cassie tells Sam that the trust between a caregiver and patient is the most important thing.
Grace and Cassie sit down together. Grace talks about having premonitions about the family, and how surprised she is to suddenly be having them about Nick. Cassie urges Grace not to worry and let things play out. Grace wants to know why she can see so much before it happens, but why she did not see what would happen to her dad. Cassie comforts Grace and tells her that her gift is not a power and that she can’t summon or wield it; sometimes it is there and sometimes it is not.
Brandon checks in with Derek about the dedication for his father. Derek asks Brandon if he has let his family members know yet about his news. He still hasn’t, and Derek urges him to come clean.
Martha demands Sam’s credit scores from Ryan, who turns down her request. She has a bad feeling about the new doctor but Cassie reassures her that he is a good man who deserves a chance. Martha refuses to back down from her opinion. Not long after, Martha digs up information online about Sam and shows Cassie. Cassie is quick to point out all the good reviews and notes that he is on several hospital boards and has published a textbook-–he is a good doctor.
Nick gets in trouble when he skips the first few periods of the school day. Sam reminds him the reason they had to leave New York was because of the arrogant troublemakers he was hanging out with. Sam reminds Nick that he has full custody, and that he can’t go live with his mom.
When Lori returns to Grey House, her brother Brandon appears at the top of the staircase in full police uniform to announce that he has a new job. A grieving Lori is overcome with worry and disappointment. The family is in disbelief that this is what Brandon wants after what happened to Jake. Cassie and Ryan meet for tea and Cassie shares Brandon’s news. She is scared for him but Ryan reassures her that Brandon needs to make his own decisions about his life. Cassie is grateful for Ryan’s friendship.
Grace and Nick meet up outside of school and start a new friendship. Nick tells Grace that he should have listened to her about not skipping periods, since he got in trouble with both the vice-principal and his dad. Nick asks Grace about what happened to her dad, and she lets him know that he passed away.
Lori tells Grace she is upset that Brandon won’t take her calls or texts. Grace urges her to reconsider and support Brandon in doing what he really feels is the right thing for himself. Lori shows up at the police station to see Brandon since he won’t take her calls. Lori continues to try to dissuade Brandon from working as a police officer. When he won’t relent, she storms off.
Sam stops by Grey House and confronts Cassie about her being his competition in Middleton. He tells her that he thinks what she is doing is dangerous. Cassie explains that she has never told anyone not to see a doctor, just that she believes in alternatives and in treating the whole person. Sam walks out, angered by her attitude.
The day after their argument, Sam visits Grey House and Cassie gives him a tea of dandelion root and chicory. Sam apologizes but will not say he is wrong. He knows George really needs a few tests and asks for Cassie’s help to get him into the office.
Cassie and Lori sit down to talk. Lori says she is happy with her life, and that she is excited to see all of the improvements at Grey House. Cassie announces that she is happy to be opening up Grey House again as a bed and breakfast. But when George seems to be in pain again, Cassie encourages him to go and see Sam. He refuses, so she him to bring some extra pies she made down to the café. For this, he’s glad to be of service.
Lori drops by the town’s newspaper office, the Middleton Eagle and visits with Jerry, her former boss. Lori submits a letter to the editor about her dad. Jerry says he will run the letter in the Sunday paper, but that the newspaper will be closing down. He just does not have any takers for getting some help to run the business, and can’t do it on his own any longer.
Nick is gunning for trouble again. Grace sees him at school and he shows her a statue of a falcon he has taken. Grace is appalled – it is named Harry and is a Middleton tradition! She urges him to return it. While they are arguing, the vice-principal sees Nick and he quickly shoves the statue into Grace’s locker.
Ryan stops by the Bell, Book and Candle and tells Cassie about an important dinner that weekend he must attend. His ex-fiancée and her husband will be there and he is unhappy at the thought of going alone. Cassie offers to go with him. Stephanie sees this interaction and asks Cassie if they are going on a date. Cassie defers and says that they are just friends. Cassie sees Ryan later at the café and just wants to confirm that they are going to the dinner just as friends, and Ryan concurs.
On his first assignment, Brandon sets up a speed trap and is instructed, per the Mayor’s orders, to issue tickets, not warnings. To the Mayor’s surprise, Brandon soon stops Martha and gives her a ticket. She asks for her license back and Brandon lets her know that it has expired. Things start really going south when Brandon asks her to step out of the car! The situation gets even worse when Brandon discovers that Martha has a pile of unpaid parking tickets on her record. Martha threatens to call Derek but he won’t relent—he is going to have Martha’s car towed!
George drops off the extra pies at the Bistro Café and Sam is there. He apologizes to George and offers to buy George a piece of pie as a peace offering. He warms up to Sam because of this, and finally agrees to let Sam do a quick work up, free of charge.
Lori stops in to see Cassie at the store and asks for something for writer’s block. She complains about having to write another article she does not care about. Cassie advises her that she may need to change direction, and that she should find a quiet place to gather her thoughts. In Cassie’s sitting room, Lori and George look over a box of items that Cassie had saved. Lori discovers many items that belonged to her dad, and she and George fondly look over stories that Lori wrote for her father.
Nick thanks Grace for not ratting him out to the vice principal about the falcon. She gives Nick her locker combination and tells him he better get Harry out of her locker or she will get him in trouble. Grace goes back to school to get her biology book, and when she opens her locker Harry falls out. Her timing is terrible—the vice principal happens to be nearby, and sees the whole thing. The VP has to call the police so he can file an insurance report, and Brandon happens to be the officer on the case. The vice principal lets Grace know that this incident will show up on her permanent record. Later, Grace confronts Nick about not taking the blame for stealing the falcon, and she knows what he is really about.
Later at the police station Martha shows up to complain to Derek about Brandon. As she is doing so Lori stops by with some soup for her brother. She overhears Martha making a ruckus about Brandon, and asks if she can quote the Mayor, now that she’s freelancing for the paper. Lori and Derek both play up the risks of complaining about an officer of the law who was only doing his job. Realizing her behavior might put her under a microscope, Martha decides to pay her fines and leave well enough alone.
Sam lets Cassie know that he could find nothing wrong with George from his exam and is quite stumped. Sam is seeing a new patient at his office when he is overtaken by a sneezing fit caused by his patient’s cologne. He has a moment of clarity, noting that he will be fine once he is “away from it” and thinks of George. He goes to Cassie’s later in the evening and asks George if he can take a look around at the garage. He stops by to see Cassie to let her know that he has figured out George’s issue. He notes that George is having a reaction to the paint and chemicals he is working with. Sam seems relieved and apologizes to Cassie about thinking it was her concoctions that were contributing to George’s symptoms.
That night, siblings Lori and Brandon share a tender moment over a special pin that Lori gave Jake years ago. She pins it onto Brandon’s coat and tells him to please be careful.
Cassie talks to Grace about Harry the falcon, and that she knows it was Nick and not Grace. The next morning, Grace decides to confide to the vice principal that the perpetrator was really Nick, but before she can do so, Nick walks in and confesses.
Over dinner, Nick and Sam share a heartfelt conversation. Sam takes responsibility for moving them so suddenly to Middleton, and he knows that now Nick is acting out as a result. He lets Nick know that it is now time for Nick to take responsibility for his own actions.
The family prepares to head to Jake’s memorial ceremony. Lori reaches a decision and submits a letter of resignation to her current job. She is hoping to stay in Middleton and work for Jerry at the local newspaper. Ryan comes to Grey House to offer the family a ride to Jake’s ceremony. Martha dedicates a wing of City Hall to Jake, and brings Cassie to the podium to speak. She keeps her speech short and sweet, as the loving husband and father would have liked. The silver lining for Cassie, and for the rest of them, is that the whole family is now back together, celebrating the life of the man they all love.
- Catherine Bell as Cassie Nightingale
- Bailee Madison as Grace Russell
- James Denton as Dr. Sam Radford
- Catherine Disher as Martha Tinsdale
- Anthony Lemke as Ryan Elliott
- Peter MacNeill as George O'Hanrahan
- Kylee Evans as Stephanie
- Noah Cappe as Derek Sanders
- Hannah Endicott-Douglas as Lori Russell
- Dan Jeanotte as Brandon Russell
- Ashley Legget as Tara
- Niamh Wilson as Amber
- Rhys Matthew Bond as Nick Radford
- Shane Hart as Anthony
- Ron Lea as Jerry
- Rishma Malik Scott as Mrs. Cavanaugh
- Paul Giurgeu as Frisbee Kid
- Derek McGrath as Vice Principal
- Anna Hardwick as Waitress
- Perry Mucci as Patient